My SPV tripled my money, and the fees still surprised me
A 3x gross return sounded great until I saw what the management fee and carry actually took off the top.
SPV investor, several years into holding
Illustrative composite. A representative scenario built from how angel secondaries commonly play out — realistic numbers, written in the first person, not the record of a specific named person or company.
Deal snapshot
- Side
- Buying (SPV)
- Entry price (post-discount)
- $50,000
- Exit value at 3x gross
- $150,000
- Hold period
- 4 years
- Fees at entry
- Not closely reviewed
- Net proceeds after fees and carry
- Noticeably below a simple 3x of my check
A good outcome on paper
The underlying company had a strong exit, and by any normal measure the deal worked — I'd put in $50,000 and the position was reported at roughly 3x that at exit. I expected a $150,000 check, or close to it.
What the closing statement actually showed
The final distribution was meaningfully below that number. Between an annual management fee that had been accruing the whole four years and a carry on the profit above my invested capital, a real chunk of the gross return went to the vehicle rather than to me. None of it was hidden — it was all in the original subscription documents — I just hadn't read that section as carefully as I read the deal terms themselves.
What I check now before investing in any SPV
I now ask for the full fee schedule — management fee percentage, carry percentage, and any setup or transaction fee — before committing to any SPV, and I do a rough net-of-fees calculation at a few different exit multiples before deciding whether the structure makes sense for that specific deal size. A direct deal at the same entry price would have kept the full gross return; the SPV access came at a real, quantifiable cost.
What to take from this
- Get the complete fee schedule (management fee, carry, any setup fee) before investing in any SPV.
- Run a rough net-of-fees calculation at a few exit scenarios, not just the headline discount at entry.
- A direct deal at the same price keeps more of the gross return, but is typically harder to access at smaller check sizes.
Every angel who has held a position long enough eventually faces a version of this decision. For the mechanics behind stories like this one, see the guide to how secondaries work.