Withholding appliedSelling

I was slow with my W-9, and it cost me at closing

The deal was done. The delay that actually held up my money was a form I meant to send back "later."

Angel investor, first secondary sale

Illustrative composite. A representative scenario built from how angel secondaries commonly play out — realistic numbers, written in the first person, not the record of a specific named person or company.

Deal snapshot

Side
Selling
Deal status
ROFR cleared, ready to close
Missing item
Signed Form W-9
Result
Backup withholding applied to initial disbursement
Resolution
Corrected after submitting the form, funds released

Everything else was ready

ROFR window closed with no exercise, the company had signed off on the transfer, and the buyer had funds sitting in escrow. I thought I was just waiting for a wire to land.

The form I kept meaning to send

The escrow agent had asked for a signed W-9 weeks earlier, and I'd filed the email away without acting on it — nothing about it felt urgent compared to the actual negotiation. When the escrow agent processed the release, a chunk of my proceeds got withheld under backup withholding rules, specifically because there was no valid taxpayer ID on file at the time of disbursement.

Getting it fixed

I signed and returned the W-9 the same day I noticed the shortfall, and the escrow agent corrected it within about a week — this wasn't a permanent loss, just an entirely avoidable delay and a moment of real panic when a chunk of the expected wire didn't show up.

It was a genuinely small piece of paperwork holding up real money, purely because I treated it as an afterthought instead of doing it the same day I signed the purchase agreement.

What to take from this

  • Return a requested W-9 (or W-8BEN, if you're a non-US seller) as early as possible in the process.
  • Backup withholding is a punitive-rate hold specifically caused by a missing or invalid taxpayer ID — it's not the same as normal tax withholding.
  • Treat every administrative document request from escrow with the same urgency as the actual deal terms.

Every angel who has held a position long enough eventually faces a version of this decision. For the mechanics behind stories like this one, see the guide to how secondaries work.

Keep reading