I donated my stake instead of selling it
I didn't need the cash. What I needed was a way to give without a tax bill eating into it first.
Angel investor, later-career, active in charitable giving
Illustrative composite. A representative scenario built from how angel secondaries commonly play out — realistic numbers, written in the first person, not the record of a specific named person or company.
Deal snapshot
- Side
- Selling (donation, not sale)
- Sector
- Climate tech
- Position value at donation
- ~$180,000
- Vehicle
- Donor-advised fund
- Lead time needed
- ~4 months
The plan that didn't start with a sale
I had a position that had appreciated a lot from a small original check, and I already planned to give a meaningful amount to charity that year. My accountant asked a question I hadn't considered: why sell it, pay capital gains tax, and donate the after-tax cash — instead of donating the appreciated stock itself?
Why it took longer than I expected
Not every charity is set up to accept illiquid private stock directly, so I worked through a donor-advised fund that specializes in exactly this. They needed a qualified independent appraisal of the position's value — private stock above a certain donation size requires one — and their own internal process to accept and eventually plan to liquidate the shares.
Between the appraisal, the fund's acceptance process, and the company's own transfer consent (the same ROFR-adjacent process as any other transfer), the whole thing took about four months from first conversation to completed transfer.
What made it worth the timeline
I avoided capital gains tax on the appreciation entirely, and I could still claim a deduction for the full fair market value. The lesson that stuck with me: this only works if you plan for it well before a sale is already substantially negotiated. If I'd waited until I had a buyer lined up, I'd have been donating cash proceeds instead, at a real tax cost.
What to take from this
- Confirm your charity or donor-advised fund can actually accept illiquid private stock before assuming this path is available.
- Budget months, not weeks, for the appraisal and acceptance process.
- This only works cleanly if you donate the stock itself — donating cash proceeds after a sale doesn't get the same tax treatment.
Every angel who has held a position long enough eventually faces a version of this decision. For the mechanics behind stories like this one, see the guide to how secondaries work.