I chose which shares to sell, and it changed my tax bill
I'd bought into the same company three separate times. Only one of those tranches made sense to sell first.
Angel investor, ~15 checks, repeat investor in a handful of companies
Illustrative composite. A representative scenario built from how angel secondaries commonly play out — realistic numbers, written in the first person, not the record of a specific named person or company.
Deal snapshot
- Side
- Selling
- Sector
- Vertical SaaS
- Tranches held
- 3 (seed SAFE, Series A follow-on, secondary buy-in)
- Portion sold
- One tranche only
- Method used
- Specific identification
- Basis difference vs. FIFO
- ~$40,000 lower reported gain
Three checks, three different baskets
I'd invested in this company three times over four years: a small seed SAFE, a follow-on at Series A when I had pro rata rights, and a later secondary buy-in from another early investor who wanted out. Informally, it was all just "my position." For tax purposes, it was three completely separate tranches with three different cost bases and three different acquisition dates.
When a buyer approached me wanting roughly a third of my total shares, my accountant asked a question I hadn't thought about: which shares, specifically, was I selling?
FIFO versus picking
Without any documentation saying otherwise, the default is FIFO — first shares in, first shares out. That would have meant selling my earliest, lowest-basis seed shares first, which meant the largest possible taxable gain on the sale.
Instead, my accountant had me document a specific-identification election before the sale closed, naming the exact tranche — the more expensive secondary buy-in shares — as the ones being sold. Same number of shares changed hands, same price, but a meaningfully smaller taxable gain because that tranche's basis was so much higher.
The part that almost got missed
The election has to be documented at or before the sale, not decided afterward at tax time — my accountant was clear that trying to retroactively pick the "best" tranche after the fact wouldn't hold up. I signed a short letter identifying the specific shares the week before closing, and kept a copy with my records.
It's a small piece of paperwork for a real difference in what I owed. I wouldn't have thought to ask if I hadn't already had a habit of tracking each investment separately in a spreadsheet.
What to take from this
- Track each investment in the same company as a separate tranche: date, price, share count.
- Without a specific-identification election, FIFO applies by default and may not be the lowest-gain outcome.
- The election needs to be documented at or before the sale — talk to your accountant before, not after, closing.
Every angel who has held a position long enough eventually faces a version of this decision. For the mechanics behind stories like this one, see the guide to how secondaries work.