OverpaidBuying

I anchored to the headline valuation, and overpaid

I paid close to the last round's per-share price for common stock. I hadn't checked what the 409A actually said.

First-time secondary buyer, came from public-markets investing

Illustrative composite. A representative scenario built from how angel secondaries commonly play out — realistic numbers, written in the first person, not the record of a specific named person or company.

Deal snapshot

Side
Buying
Instrument
Common stock
Last preferred round price
$5.00 / share
Actual 409A common fair value at the time
$1.20 / share
Price I paid
$4.20 / share
Result
Paid roughly 3x a defensible common-stock reference price

A habit from public markets

I came into this from years of trading public stocks, where the last trade price is simply the price. When a seller told me the company's "valuation" from its recent round, I treated that per-share number as the natural starting point for negotiating my own discount, the same way I would with a public quote.

What I didn't know to ask for

What I was actually buying was common stock, not the preferred stock that priced the last round. Preferred stock carries a liquidation preference that sits ahead of common in most exit scenarios — which is exactly why a company's 409A valuation, an independent appraisal of common stock specifically, is almost always far below the last round's headline number.

I found out the actual 409A figure only after the deal had closed, when I mentioned my purchase price to another investor who asked, with visible surprise, how I'd arrived at it.

What I do differently now

I ask for the most recent 409A figure and date before ever discussing a price for common stock, and I treat it as my starting anchor, adjusted upward for how much I personally believe the preference stack will actually matter at exit — not the other way around, starting from the headline number and discounting down.

What to take from this

  • Ask the seller (or the company, if possible) for the most recent 409A figure and date before pricing a common-stock purchase.
  • A large gap between the last round's headline price and the 409A figure is normal, not a red flag — it reflects the preference stack.
  • Anchor to the 409A first, then adjust upward for your own view — not the reverse.

Every angel who has held a position long enough eventually faces a version of this decision. For the mechanics behind stories like this one, see the guide to how secondaries work.

Keep reading