A good year triggered a tax I hadn't budgeted for
I reserved for capital gains. I didn't reserve for the extra 3.8% that came with them.
Angel investor, day job in product management
Illustrative composite. A representative scenario built from how angel secondaries commonly play out — realistic numbers, written in the first person, not the record of a specific named person or company.
Deal snapshot
- Side
- Selling
- Sector
- Consumer marketplace
- Gain on sale
- ~$310,000
- Tax reserved
- Long-term capital gains rate only
- Additional owed
- NIIT, 3.8% surtax
- Result
- Had to draw from savings to cover the gap
The math I did
I sold about a third of a position that had done well, and I reserved what I thought was a generous cushion — the top long-term capital gains rate, rounded up. I felt responsible for having thought about it at all, honestly, compared to just spending the whole check.
The number my accountant added
When I sat down to file, my accountant flagged the Net Investment Income Tax — an additional 3.8% surtax that applies once your income, including the sale itself, crosses a certain threshold for the year. I'd never owed it before because my income without this sale never got close to that line. The sale itself was exactly what pushed me over it.
It wasn't a huge percentage in isolation, but on a gain this size it was a real, five-figure amount I hadn't set aside anywhere.
How I closed the gap
I had enough in savings to cover it without a real emergency, but it meant liquidating a certificate of deposit early and eating a small penalty on top of an already-avoidable surprise. The frustrating part wasn't the tax itself — it's a known rule — it's that I simply hadn't asked the right question before I set my reserve amount.
What to take from this
- Ask your accountant about NIIT exposure before setting a tax reserve on any large one-time gain.
- A single big sale can push you over a tax threshold for the year even if your normal income never gets close.
- Build in a buffer beyond the headline capital gains rate on any six-figure-plus gain.
Every angel who has held a position long enough eventually faces a version of this decision. For the mechanics behind stories like this one, see the guide to how secondaries work.